Monthly Q&A With Allan Drew
Every month, I’m going to choose the most interesting injury question I’ve received and answer it in this column. I encourage you to write with any questions pertaining to your muscular injury or joint pain.
Submit your question to Allan Drew today- click here to submit your question.
Question from Nov 1, 2007
This is from Chris, Ontario, Canada: I broke my ankle resulting in two 3 inch screws in one side and a plate with 9 screws on the other. I’ve been in physical therapy for 3 weeks I can't get the ankle to bend forward. I am doing everything I am suppose to. Is there a medication that can loosen the tendons for me to bend it again? I do not want another surgery. When I bend my ankle to stretch, I get sharp pains traveling up both sides of my leg with little range of motionAnswer
Chris, I’m not a medical doctor so I can’t prescribe meds. Besides there is no better medicine than determination. You will have to keep working with your therapist doing stretches and range of motion movements. A massage therapist can work on the muscles of the lower leg. I’m sure there was soft tissue (muscle) damage in the lower leg muscles (the calf and either side of the shin bone). Working those muscles can take some of the pressure off the ankle. The stretching should be held for only 2 seconds. There are many theories on stretching but I’ve been doing 2 second stretches for 20 years and I believe it works best. Try it, stretch to its max, count one, two and release making sure the foot comes back to relaxed position then repeat for up to ten times. If there is too much pain take a break between stretches. Your recovery is up to you, it's going to be a job, treat it as such, just do it. Yours in Wellness, Allan Drew
Question from Jun 1, 2007
Low back, mostly left side, in roughly a right-triangle-shaped region with one leg of the triangle going up the left side of my spine from the base to about 6-7" above buttock, and the other leg runs parallel to the floor, from spine to about 3" away from spine (to the left). Connect the ends of those two lines, and you have my "pain triangle."
It feels mostly like muscle tightness, although at the peak of the triangle, there is a mild but sharp pain (only sometimes) that seems to be at a vertebra. This exclusively occurs on the left side.
Strangely, movement does not seem to be inhibited, even though I have felt this pain daily for almost a year now. Two weeks ago, I started running 1-2 miles a day, and it feels better when I run, but always is at its worst when I first wake up. I have tried 3 different mattresses. I can perform back stretches quite well, seemingly without restriction, but also without benefit. It is worth noting that for about a year, my job consisted of 5-6 hours of heavy lifting in a stressful environment 5 days each week. But the pain didn't happen until I *stopped* that job and took a job where I sit all night!
I'm not active at all (student, study all day, drive to work, work while sitting all night until midnight). Male age 24.
Answer
Scott, the pain triangle you are experiencing is the area of the quadratus lumborum muscle but I don't think it's that muscle causing your problem. The job of heaving lifting would cause you to use core muscles most likely the psoas muscles. These attach to the lumbar spine in the area you describe as the pain triangle. The sitting you're now doing would allow those muscles to shorten causing the pain. Most of the back stretches I've seen over the years do not include the most important, the lunge stretch. Kneel on one knee (I recommend a small pillow under the knee), with the opposite leg reach out in front of you as far as you can comfortable. Lean slightly forward making sure the ankle of the front leg is ahead of the knee of that same leg. You should feel as though you are doing the split and feel the stretch in the groin (sometimes in the low back). At this point lean your upper torso back gently, hold for 2 seconds than lean forward releasing the stretch, repeat 10 times. I find that holding on to a stuffed sofa or chair helps with balance. Stretch both sides but you will find that one side is tighter then the other. Spend more time on the tight side but don't neglect the other side. Continue this stretch 2 to 3 times a day for a couple of weeks, it's important to continue to stretch even after you're feeling better. Those muscles have the memory of being tight and it will take time to retrain that memory. Let me know if this works for you.
Yours in Wellness,
Allan Drew
Question from Apr 1, 2007
April 2007 - Colleen from New York asks about a groin pull.
I'm a 42-year-old distance runner. On a run a couple of weeks ago, there were patches of ice causing me to tighten my legs more than usual. About 5 miles into my run I felt a tightening on the inside of my left thigh. After a few minutes I felt a sharp pain. The pain was severe enough to make me walk home. I didn't run for 12 days and when I tried again I had to stop after one mile. Have I torn the muscle? What should I do?
Answer
A groin pull would include one of the adductor muscles. The most likely candidate would be the gracilis, a long, narrow (the diameter of a cigar) muscle that runs from the pubic bone to the lower leg. Have your massage therapist work the area. They should be able to determine which muscle is involved. Massage the area to loosen the fibers then stretch. There are numerous adductor stretches, find the one that pulls on the tender area. I believe in the two-second stretch, hold for a count of two, release and repeat. If it is the gracilis the stretch that should work would be to sit in a chair with your feet on the floor. Place your left ankle on your right knee; apply pressure to the left knee toward the floor. You should feel the stretch on the muscle. Again, hold for 2 seconds and release, repeat 10 to 20 times. Stretch three or more times a day. Keep stretching until you are 100%. I would not run for a week or two and then only run for a short distance - for you that might be a mile- if it feels okay, take the next day off before you run again. Do not increase your mileage too quickly. I understand how difficult it is for a dedicated runner to not be able to run but too much too soon would only delay your full return. Do some cross-training, cycling or swimming if it doesn't aggravate the injury.
Yours in Wellness,
Allan Drew
Question from Mar 1, 2007
Cathy, RMT, Ontario, Canada
I was wondering if you have dealt with any clients that have had pacemakers. I have a client who is experiencing overall fatigue and is also getting pain in his left arm around the insertion of the middle deltoid or possible origin of the brachialis. It is worse on internal rotation. So two questions, as far as I know you should stay away from the site of the pacemaker and any leads what's your take on the subject. Client is a not very active 85-year-old male. Thanks for your input.
Answer
Cathy, the fatigue and pain in the left arm has me concerned. Has your client had an examination by his cardiologist? Rule out the possibility that the heart isn't the cause. Having ruled out his heart as the problem, begin muscle testing. First, test the deltoid, have him hold his arm to the side with the arm parallel to the floor; apply light pressure pushing his arm toward the floor while he resists. If there is pain or a weak muscle response it's probably the deltoid. Second, have him bend his arm to 90 degrees apply pressure to straighten his arm with him resisting. Pain or weakness would suggest the brachialis or biceps is the culprit. If neither of these tests produces significant discomfort then the problem is likely referred pain from the subscapularis. This is my bet as to where the problem lies, the subscapularis is an internal rotator. Work from a prone and a supine position also check the teres major. And, yes, stay away from the site of the pacemaker and leads. Good luck.
Yours in Wellness,
Allan Drew
Question from Feb 1, 2007
Carlene writes: I have RLS (Restless Leg Syndrome). My doctor is suggesting that I take the drug Requip. I'd like to stay away from drugs. Will massage help?
Answer
Carlene, The medical establishment considers RLS as idiopathic (cause not known) but label it as a neurological (having to do with nerves) disorder. As with the neuralgia case I wrote about (refer to Introduction to the right of this column), massage may deliver some relief although they claim there is no known cure. My experience with this syndrome is limited but the results have been mostly very good using deep tissue massage. One case concerns a pregnant woman where massage only helped temporally. RLS in pregnant woman seems to be a third trimester problem that dissipates after delivery.
I would recommend alternative methods of treatment before taking medication including: massage (deep), exercise (walking, aerobics, biking) and stretching. Also, depletion of iron, magnesium and chronic diseases should be checked. The use of tobacco, caffeine and alcohol can be a contributing factor.
The best information I could find comes from the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke. www.ninds.nih.gov/disorders/restless_legs/detail_restless_legs.htm
Please keep me informed about your results. Does anyone out there have anything to add? The more we share this kind of information the sooner we'll find ways to heal without the use of drugs.
Yours in Wellness,
Allan Drew
Question from Jan 1, 2007
I'm wondering if you can help me with RSD as it pertains to my ankle.
I broke metatarslas 2,3, and 4 on 10/22, and have been doing PT under the guidance of my orthopedist. I have had minimal progress, with incerasing pain, due to, I am told, the RSD. Frankly, I simply don't understand RSD, but the pain is intense.
Do you feel massage could help with the RSD, (my fractures are supposedly healed, and I'm sure I still have some soft tissue injury)?
Answer
Ruth, RSD (Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy) is a syndrome of abnormal and intense pain from an injury, surgery, or trauma. This pain is usually associated with the sympathetic nervous system, the part of the autonomic nervous system that deals with the "fight or flight" reaction. RSD is thought to be a severe reaction to the injury by this nervous system. The key word here is "thought." There are still medical mysteries that have no clear understanding as to what, where, or why they occur, or how to cure them. Unfortunately, RSD is such a case. But RSD can be managed with sympathetic blockage using local anesthetic injections and pharmacologic intervention, i.e., corticosteroids, calcium channel blockers, alpha-adrenergic compounds, oral local anesthetics, anticonvulsants, and tricyclic antidepressants.
Basically, medical experts don't know for sure why so much pain is present. They try various techniques and compounds until they find a combination that works for you.
Now to your question about whether massage will help or not, the answer is that I don't know. But any time you have a broken bone you also have soft tissue damage. That can be addressed by massage. Physical therapy should be included to assist in the movement of muscle tissue. Movement is very important in the health of muscle tissue - Use but Don't Abuse. What I mean is, don't overdo. Yes, do get a massage. After one treatment you'll have an idea of whether or not you feel better. The massage will help on two levels: (1) your therapist can work on the muscles of the lower leg and, through touch, determine the condition of the muscle tissue; and (2) the relaxation the massage produces may help settle the sympathetic nervous system. I believe massage is worth a try.
Yours in Wellness,
Allan Drew
Question from Nov 12, 2006
Answer
November 12, 2006
This week is not a letter, but a story about a client. I saw Tim for the first time in 2000. He is a 46-year-old teaching tennis pro, able to play with his left or right hand. Tim had tennis elbow in both elbows and was fearful he would not be able to continue in his profession. I suggested he choose to play either left- or right-handed so the unused elbow would have a chance to heal. Tennis elbow (tendonitis) is the inflammation of the epicondyle of the humerus. What I believe happens are that the muscles become so tight they pull on the tendon that attach to the bone, causing the pain. I worked on both left and right arms equally. The surprise was that the side he continued to use healed first. He was playing with easy, not hard strokes, and I think the motion of using, but not abusing, the arm aided in the healing by putting the muscles through their range of motion.
This not the end of the story. Tim came to see me this past week. He's continued to teach, but has continuing problems from some tendonitis of the elbow, and shoulder soreness due to over-use or repetitive movements. My approach this time was to look at the problem from an overall perspective, starting at the shoulder and working down to the arm. What I found were tight rotator cuff muscles. The tightest and most significant of these was the subscapularis, the muscle under the scapular. When I worked this muscle, Tim felt the pain in his elbow. After the session he said he felt less pain. I think I'm on the right track this time.
The lesson I continue to learn is to not allow myself to fall into a pattern of assuming that because my last client was helped by a certain procedure that it will help the next client. It is necessary for me to keep an open mind and not become routine or complacent. Perhaps that is a lesson we can all learn.
Yours in Healing,
Allan Drew
Question from Nov 5, 2006
I'm a woman, 25, with calf pain from about two inches above the heel to the top of the calf, right below the knee. It's a sharp pain that radiates the entire calf, and when I stretch, sometimes it hurts so much it feels like they're almost numb.
I started running again, about 3 months ago, after not being active for a couple of years. At first, I thought I had shin splints because my calves were so tight, but after the shin pain went away, the calf pain began. I stretch before and after each run, but nothing seems to be getting better. They hurt the most when I run and sometimes when I take long strides while race walking.
Answer
Kelsey, what you have is an over-use injury. You asked your muscles to do more than they were use to doing. The muscle responds by tightening. My guess is that the tightening occurred over days or weeks until the pain began. I recommend you find a competent massage therapist, someone who works on injuries. The muscles involved are the soleus and the gastrocnemius. The gastroc is a two joint muscle, meaning it assist in the flexion of the knee and plantar flexion of the ankle. The soleus flexes only the ankle. The attachments for the gastroc are behind and slightly above the knee and the Achilles tendon at the ankle. But, both muscles should be tested. One way to determine which muscle is tight is to stretch your calves, first with a straight knee, hold for 2 seconds, then let your knee bend and continue the stretch for 2 more seconds. The straight (or locked) knee stretches the gastroc, a bent knee stretches the soleus. Stretch the muscle that feels tight, or possibly, both muscles. I do recommend at least one session with a massage therapist. And, do a lot of stretching, several times a day. I believe in the 2 second stretch, hold and release then repeat.
To find a competent therapist ask them the question you asked me. If they have an understanding of the muscles involved, you may have found the right one. Working the calves can be painful. Remember, you are in control of your body, if it's too painful, ask them to use less pressure. There should be some discomfort but not flinching pain and that, you have the right to determine not the therapist.
Yours in Health,
Allan Drew
Question from Oct 29, 2006
This weeks question comes from Caitlin of Boston.
I am writing because I'm trying to gather information / resources on Neuropathy for my grandmother, who was diagnosed with the condition close to a year ago, and in addition to my inquiries to the True North folks, Chris suggested I contact you - as she believes you have had some success using massage to treat neuropathy. My grandmother has been seeing a neurologist in the Boston area (where she lives) but doesn't feel she has adequately answered all her questions so she's seeking out additional opinions and resources. She has also been doing water therapy and other physical therapy related to her a fall she took last spring. She knows her neuropathy cannot be "cured" but wants to know if there are things she can be doing to help slow the spreading up her ankles and legs.
Answer
Caitlin, I'm including a story from my book pertaining to neurophy.
One of my clients, a doctor, came into my office with pain in the palms of his hands and the bottom of his feet. His doctor told him he had neuralgia (pain along the distribution of sensory nerves) and he was told to get used to it, and "...it will only get worse." He asked if I could help. I told him what I tell all my clients, "If it's muscular, probably." One week after the first session he returned, held out his hands and said, "It's working!" After three sessions, the pain was gone.
There may be a way to ease the pain. I believe that in some cases the nerves may be trapped in or irritated by tight muscle tissue. With this client I worked the muscles of the lower leg; the calf muscles and muscles on either side of the shin. It might be worth a try with your grandmother. Find a competent massage therapist who does orthopedic or sports massage.
If the legs are too sensitive to massage the therapist could start out with very, very light pressure. What I have learned is that the body will adapt to the pressure if given time. Even laying the hands on the tender area gently can start the process. Don't give up. If your grandmother is in this area I would be happy to see what I could do. Good luck and keep me informed.
Yours in Healing,
Allan
Question from Oct 8, 2006
This weeks question comes from Nora of Boston,
According to my Dr. I have frozen shoulder. I went to a massage therapist who seemed to know what they were doing. After five weeks of therapy most of the pain went away but the range of motion has not improved. What more can I do.
At rest there is no pain. Only when I try to lift my arm up from my side either lifting from the front or side it only moves about 10 degrees then the ach begins in the shoulder.
I walk 2 or 3 times a week for 2 miles. I'm a female, 52.
Answer
Nora, frozen shoulder is seen mostly, in woman 40 to 60 years old. One of the doctors I work with, who works in woman's medicine, believes there's a hormonal piece. What I have found is an emotional piece that may play into the mix. (See Monthly Update for October)
What you describe is not unusual. Often the pain dissipates with massage therapy but the Range of Motion (ROM) returns slowly. Check with your therapist, did they work the subscapularis, (teres major, and latissimus dorsi area)? The subscapularis is reached from the arm pit, a not so comfortable muscle to work. And one that takes very strong hands on the part of the massage therapist. Also, you need to stretch the shoulder the best way you can. The stretching should be uncomfortable but not painful. I suggest using the 2 second stretch, hold only for 2 seconds, and release than stretch again. I have a client that is continuing to heal. She is out of pain and is able to sleep better but, it has taken 4 ½ months. She went from 10% ROM to 40% and is continuing to heal.
Depending on the individual, full healing and full ROM can take time. Keep moving, use the arm as much as possible. Movement is healthy for muscle tissue, and stretch. As long as you are out of pain and you can sleep - be patient and if you are dealing with an emotional problem - deal with that as well. Another client's ROM returned in the same time frame as her emotional healing. Keep me updated on your recovery, good luck.
Addendum: 10/12/06 - I neglected to add: often with a frozen shoulder that has been immobile for a significant time there may be some ‘gumming up' in the joint from non-use. If this is the case it will be necessary to break-up the fibers in the joint by someone who knows how to do the procedure. I have the client bend their elbow 90 degrees. I hold the elbow while allowing their forearm and hand to rest against my shoulder in a relaxed manner. Placing my other hand in top of the clients shoulder I push from the elbow toward the shoulder with a twisting motion, clockwise and counter-clockwise. There should not be any pain. If there is restriction in the area it should begin to feel looser as you continue the motion. This should increase the ROM.
Yours in Healing,
Allan Drew